Sunday, November 26, 2017

The Clouds Of Sils Maria - Round and Round We Go

My dive on this Black Friday of 2017 was into the French/German/Swiss co production movie “The Clouds Of Sils Maria directed by Olivier Assayas and starring the veteran French actress Juliette Binoche, and two up and coming American actresses, Kristen Stewart of “Twilight” fame and Chloe Grace Moretz.

This is a story that is told in mirrored levels.  At base, there is a story about the relationship between two women, an established CEO of some mythical corporations and her younger protege.  It is a study of the weariness of age and experience versus the energetic yet blind grasp of youth.  The actual movie is about Binoche who as a famous established actress on the downward slope of a long career agrees to play the older CEO in the just described story and her young personal assistant played by Kristen Stewart.  The essential theme of this movie is simply that the relationship between these two characters in the movie that we are actually viewing is mirrored precisely in the fictional movie that is the subject of the plot.  And so we see many scenes where the actress and her assistant are rehearsing scenes but there is this question of at what level we should be interpreting these conversations.  Are we hearing a conversation between the actress and the assistant in the movie or the script of the fictional movie?  If this sounds confusing, it is meant to be and it kind of works to make what they actually say more interesting.

I don’t usually like movies about people making movies.  The idea that what  “artists” find worth talking about is obsessing about their own creative efforts is navel gazing indulgence of the most worthless kind.  “Clouds Of Sils Maria” works because of this gimmick of confusing the levels of abstraction.  There is even a kind of 4th wall further abstraction in the choice of the real actresses to play these parts as they really do have this kind of old pro and new hungry kid vibe in their actual careers.  The process is intriguing.  What the movie actually tells us is something that I could not fathom.  

The scene for much of the movie was very cool as it is set in the Swiss Alps in an area which has what is called the Maloja Pass.  This is a beautiful area and their is a cloud phenomena that exist there where low clouds drift down the valley between mountains evoking a magical surrealistic scene.  This made me think of that most literate of naval gazers Friedrich Nietzsche and his time in the Swiss Alps and his “Thus Spoke Zarathustra”.  

Monday, November 13, 2017

Manhunt Unabomber: a strange disquieting tale.
My exploration for this cold November Saturday was the 8 hour binge watch of the Netflicks offering, Manhunt Unabomber.  Not quite a pure binge because I drifted in and out of sleep for the first couple episodes.  but not so strangely, I immediately picked up the thread in episode three  There were two themes at work in this show. 

The first was the introduction of the use of linguistic and text analysis to profile suspects.  It was a challenge to keep this part of the drama compelling.  They portrayed a kind of puzzle solving process with different characters contributing new avenues of analysis.  The fact that the unabomber, Ted Kaczynski had published a 35000  word diatribe on the dangers the out technocratic age made that is good approach but it was hard to see how this would be broadly useful because many criminals don't do a lot of writing.  In order to build drama on this theme, they had to create a "pull back the furniture and arrange the jigsaw clues" approach which reminded me of the "The Imatation Game" and the code breaking in WWII.  What was off was that they didn't use computers, which by 1995 were being used to for text analysis involving such topics as the authorship of Shakespeare's plays.  I do understand that this kind of data inputting would have killed the drama.  Also this text analysis, while able to define certain things which turned out to be true about the unabomber, the real reason why he was caught was the publication of this manifesto and the fact that his brother recognized who the author was.  So they had to unbelievably connect the dots to make this linguistic profiling important. All of this is admittedly a bit picky, maybe a little clumsy but not a show stopper.

It is the second theme that was more of a problem for me. The show concentrates on two main characters, an FBI agent named Fitzgerald and the unabomber.  The implication in this is that they are in a kind of Holmes/Moriarity kind of two sides of the same coin.  Fitzgerald become so obsessed with finding the unabomber that he destroys his marriage and his relationship with his children.  He double crosses fellow agents the help him and he crassly uses his close relationship to a lady professor of linguistics.  This equating of the protagonist and the antagonist is made very obvious in a very early scene of the first episode  where we initially meet the Fitzgerald carrying rabbits back to his remote cabin.  It only becomes apparent later that this is a scene from the future beyond the events of the series where he has bought into the unabomber's ideas.  This idea just doesn't work very well.  The unabomber is a horrendous character who while they attempt to explain his behavior, shows a kind of attitude where he seems unable to recognize human beings and he justifies his bombs as a way to get his message out.  Whatever Fitzgerald's faults, he is a normal human being caught up in an obsession.  I not sure what the message was here except maybe "There but for the grace of God go you or I"  Sometimes it's just better to have good guys and bad guys and leave it at that.

A couple of other things that made me hesitate to like this series  During the trial machinations at the end it is implied  the the unabomber was not given his day in court.  His court appointed defense and the judge railroaded the system because they could force him to go for an insanity defense which was the one thing that he did not want because he was not insane.  His only alternative was to plead guilty.  This was certainly food for thought but it was odd to find oneself sympathizing with this monster.   There were other efforts to explain what caused his behavior.  Most of one episode was devoted to his participation in a bizarre psychological experiment that was conducted at Harvard which certainly would be considered unethical and cruel by almost any standard except the 50s paranoia that consumed academia.   This is all interesting but it really amounts to a distraction from the clear fact the the unabomber was born with an potential genius IQ level but he was also born with some type of missing capacity for empathy so that he was a classic example of what we now call a sociopathic personality.  This question of Nature versus Nurture while true to some degree serves to kind of obscures this basic point. 

Finally he was sentenced to a life sentence with no possiblity of parole  Here I will quote the section of wikepedia on his imprisonment.
When asked if he was afraid of losing his mind in prison, Kaczynski replied:
"No, what worries me is that I might in a sense adapt to this environment and come to be comfortable here and not resent it anymore. And I am afraid that as the years go by that I may forget, I may begin to lose my memories of the mountains and the woods and that's what really worries me, that I might lose those memories, and lose that sense of contact with wild nature in general. But I am not afraid they are going to break my spirit."
In 2016, it was reported that early on in his imprisonment Kaczynski had befriended Ramzi Yousef and Timothy McVeigh, the perpetrators of the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and the Oklahoma City bombing, respectively. The trio discussed religion and politics and formed a friendship which lasted until McVeigh's execution in 2001.
The Labadie Collection, part of the University of Michigan's Special Collections Library, houses Kaczynski's correspondence with over 400 people since his arrest, including replies, legal documents, publications, and clippings.  In 2012, Kaczynski responded to the Harvard Alumni Association's directory inquiry for the upcoming fiftieth reunion of the class of 1962; he listed his occupation as "prisoner" and his eight life sentences as "awards".   \

So it sounds like he has been able to makes an interesting life for himself in prison.  Oh did I mention that he killed 3 people maimed and injured 23 others and wrote in his diary that he was disappointed that he wasn't getting more fatalities. As a general rule, I would be against capital punishment but there are always exceptions.  The reality of evil, what it is and what we should do about it?

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

I slowly submerged into the 1955 Ingmar Bergman film "The Smiles Of A Summer Evening".  This is said to be one of his few comedic films but it was really a kind of existential farce but all's well that ends well I suppose.  It just wasn't very funny.  Everyone in the film was somehow at some point humiliated but by the end everyone was where they wanted to be with the person that they wanted to be with.  A calm but maybe not happy ending.  I ran into a great review by the master movie reviewer Pauline Kael.

Late in 1955, Ingmar Bergman made a nearly perfect work—the exquisite carnal comedy Smiles of a Summer Night. It was the distillation of elements he had worked with for several years, in the 1952 Secrets of Women (originally called Waiting Women), the 1954 A Lesson in Love, and the early 1955 Dreams; these episodic comedies of infidelity are like early attempts or drafts. They were all set in the present, and the themes were plainly exposed; the dialogue, full of arch epigrams, was often clumsy, and the ideas, like the settings, were frequently depressingly middle class and novelettish. Structurally, they were sketchy and full of flashbacks. There were scattered lovely moments, as if Bergman’s eye were looking ahead to the visual elegance of Smiles of a Summer Night, but the plot threads were still woolly. Smiles of a Summer Night was made after Bergman directed a stage production of The Merry Widow, and he gave the film a turn-of-the-century setting. Perhaps it was this distance that made it possible for him to create a work of art out of what had previously been mere clever ideas. He not only tied up the themes in the intricate plot structure of a love roundelay, but in using the lush period setting, he created an atmosphere that saturated the themes. The film is bathed in beauty, removed from the banalities of short skirts and modern-day streets and shops, and removed in time, it draws us closer.

Bergman found a high style within a set of boudoir farce conventions: in Smiles of a Summer Night, boudoir farce becomes lyric poetry. The sexual chases and the round dance are romantic, nostalgic; the coy bits of feminine plotting are gossamer threads of intrigue. The film becomes an elegy to transient love: a gust of wind and the whole vision may drift away.

There are four of the most talented and beautiful women ever to appear in one film: as the actress, the great Eva Dahlbeck, appearing onstage, giving a house party, and in one inspired suspended moment, singing “Freut euch des Lebens”; the impudent love-loving maid, Harriet Andersson—as a blonde, but as opulent and sensuous as in her other great roles; Margit Carlqvist as the proud, unhappy countess; Ulla Jacobsson as the eager virgin.

Even Bergman’s epigrams are much improved when set in the quotation marks of a stylized period piece. (Though I must admit I can’t find justification for such bright exchanges as the man’s question, “How could a woman ever love a man?” and her response: “A woman’s view is seldom based on aesthetics. Anyone can always turn out the light.” I would have thought you couldn’t get a laugh on that one unless you tried it in an old folks’ home, but Bergman is a man of the theater—audiences break up on it.) Bergman’s sensual scenes are much more charming, more unexpected in the period setting: when they are deliberately unreal they have grace and wit. How different it is to watch the same actor and actress making love in the stuck elevator of Secrets of Women and in the golden pavilion of Smiles of a Summer Night. Everything is subtly improved in the soft light and delicate, perfumed atmosphere.

In Bergman’s modern comedies, marriages are contracts that bind the sexes in banal boredom forever. The female strength lies in convincing the man that he’s big enough to act like a man in the world, although secretly he must acknowledge his dependence on her. (J. M. Barrie used to say the same thing in the cozy, complacent Victorian terms of plays like What Every Woman Knows; it’s the same concept that Virginia Woolf raged against—rightly, I think—in Three Guineas.) The straying male is just a bad child—but it is the essence of maleness to stray. Bergman’s typical comedy heroine, Eva Dahlbeck, is the woman as earth mother who finds fulfillment in accepting the infantilism of the male. In the modern comedies, she is a strapping goddess with teeth big enough to eat you and a jaw and neck to swallow you down; Bergman himself is said to refer to her as “the Woman Battleship.”

But in Smiles of a Summer Night, though the roles of the sexes are basically the same, the perspective is different. In this vanished setting, nothing lasts, there are no winners in the game of love; all victories are ultimately defeats—only the game goes on. When Eva Dahlbeck, as the actress, wins back her old lover (Gunnar Björnstrand), her plot has worked—but she really hasn’t won much. She caught him because he gave up; they both know he’s defeated. Smiles is a tragic comedy; the man who thought he “was great in guilt and in glory” falls—he’s “only a bumpkin.” This is a defeat we can all share—for have we not all been forced to face ourselves as less than we hoped to be? There is no lesson, no moral—the women’s faces do not tighten with virtuous endurance (the setting is too unreal for endurance to be plausible). The glorious old Mrs. Armfeldt (Naima Wifstrand) tells us that she can teach her daughter nothing—or, as she puts it: “One can never protect a single human being from any kind of suffering. That’s what makes one so tremendously weary.”

Smiles of a Summer Night was the culmination of Bergman’s “rose” style, and he has not returned to it. (The Seventh Seal, perhaps his greatest “black” film, was also set in a remote period.) The Swedish critic Rune Waldekranz has written that Smiles of a Summer Night “wears the costume of the fin de siècle period for visual emphasis of the erotic comedy’s fundamental premise—that the step between the sublime and the ridiculous in love is a short one, but nevertheless one that a lot of people stub their toe on. Although suffering from several ingenuous slapstick situations, Smiles of a Summer Night is a comedy in the most important meaning of the word. It is an arabesque on an essentially tragic theme, that of man’s insufficiency, at the same time as it wittily illustrates the belief expressed fifty years ago by Hjalmar Söderberg that the only absolutes in life are ‘the desire of the flesh and the incurable loneliness of the soul.’”


Saturday, April 29, 2017

I Think I'm Turning Japanese I Really Think So

I was watching a Chess tournament a while back which well establishes my dork cred and the German GM who was commenting the games mentioned that he hadn't been doing anything else but binge watching a Netflix show called Terrace House: Boys and Girls In The City  which was quite strange because he didn't understand a word that they were saying.  What he was talking about was a Japanese reality show quite out of the mold of any reality show that I've ever seen.

The premise of this show is simple.  3 men 3 women as house mates and that is it.  They continue  to live their normal real lives in every regard.  Dealing with friends and family,  jobs and education, everything proceeds as usual.  They can choose to leave at anytime and almost all choose to do so at some point when either they just get to busy,  feel that they need to fully commit to something else, or for more personal reasons regarding hazy and unsettled romantic commitments.  No one must choose what's behind door A or B. but the premise of the show is that these are people who are currently not in relationships and Terrace house is an arena for new relationships.  So, if your life becomes to busy, career demands to insistent or  you realize that the "chemistry" is not there then it seems like you are expected to move on.  The show went on for 46 weeks and over that time there wee 17 different participants.

This is a reality show and the very important point is that these people have agreed to be recorded pretty everywhere they go 24/7.  Each half hour show is created with skillful editing of a previous week of filming so that interesting narratives are created in this way.  Terrace House: Boys and Girls In The City, however it may be done, creates such an transparent omnipresence that I am completely convinced of being shown a real story in real time about real people which can't be the case so I have no explanation of how this is possible.  I revel in my naivete.

The terrace house itself is something right out of Frank Lloyd Wright with open spaces and linear ambiance.  Every room has been painted the some variation of warm white so that people appear as colorful figures on and empty canvas.

One other unique part of this show is that there is a kind of Greek Chorus of Japanese celebrities who periodically break in to give humorous and many times insightful commentary on what they have just seen with everyone else in TV land. This provides levels of self reference to the show.  In fact the actual members of the house are watching themselves on TV and also watching the chorus so where this ends round and round we go?

So what comes across?  First, the Japanese best face put squarely forward.  Tokyo looks like some sort of wonderous future mega-world clean and beautiful.  Second, pretty young people living sane grounded lives.  Lots of bowing and discrete hands covering laughing faces.  Shoes off, lounge able low furniture, and even an occasional raw fish dish.  A realization of just how interesting the lives of real people can be when presented in subtle clarity.  Western culture done the right way, in the East.

One caveat; the subtitles go by pretty quick but it's all pretty conversational and just ignore the proper names as you will be fine.

Monday, March 13, 2017


Bright Lights Small City

My downward spiral on this Snowy March afternoon was into the German movie "Bright Light" which is a Netflix offering.  This is a well acted tale of four people who meet up in the childhood town of two of these people.  I'm just going to designate these folks as A,B C, and D because I don't remember names and they are of no consequence.  A is a woman.  This is her childhood town and as it turns she is the primary character.  B is her younger boyfriend.  This is also C's hometown and as we discover he was once involved with A but is now gay and in a relationship with D who is a psychoanalyst and as it turns likes to play psychological games.  The first half of the movie builds tension.  There are strange happenings but not clearly supernaturally strange and there is this ominous shaking and sound because there is a massive strip mining operation going on right next to the house and the whole area is marked for mining destruction. Tension builds. Secrets are revealed.  A has sublimated a lot of guilt because she had outed a gay boy and he had killed himself.  The psychologist D, beside spouting a lot of mumbo jumbo which I probably should have payed more attention to is adept at vibing people out concerning  the fluid sexuality in all people.  Wine is drunk and the 'tell people how you really feel' monster rears its ugly head.
     The later part of this movie is very confused and dream like all the way through.  The only way that I was able to impose some meaning on this was the artificial theme of something akin to Dicken's "A Christmas Carol"  where this woman is visited by what her behavior leads to and she has the opportunity to change and make things right.  This is just my best guess on the meaning of the movie and unfortunately it is not well pointed to in the actual movie.  So, all in all, a promising start and a confused ending.