I went of the deep end with a movie from 2011 with an intriguing title "The Future". As a quick summary, this is a relationship story about a man and a women having a kind of collective midlife crisis that leads to a surreal set of fantastical happenings at the end of which we are not quite sure whether this is to be judged as growth or the end of their being together. This is designated as a dramedy but it failed in both for me. It was not clear how to judge the beginning state of their relationship. They are presented as bored unchallenged people who look, dress, and act the same. The thing is that they seem to be comfortable with each others and on the same wavelength. And what good comedy is found in this part of the movie and as the movie continues it falls away and the end of the movie is kind of a nothingburger. So I liked these people at the start but they became more and more sad. I really didn't like the part where the women goes off on an affair in a very random way and moves in with older very oily guy. The film was directed by a women director but this portrayal seemed quite unimaginative and sexist in its "the woman manifests her boredom by becoming a sexual object" Surprise Surprise. The guy just become a door to door ecological salesman. The was an unbalance that I could not forgive. So at the end of the movie no regrets. There is a subtheme with a coming adoption of a mysterious talking cat which gets scuttled with their problems. Even with the dime store philosophizing this was just sad.
Friday, September 24, 2021
Sunday, May 3, 2020
I tiptoed into shallow waters of Hulu's newest production. "Normal People" on this drizzly Sunday afternoon in May. This is the sixth week of the social distance quarantine from the 2020 pandemic and I would say that I am a pretty low bar consumer of the television but this was hard to make it through. I thought their were only eight episodes but then discovered that it was twelve and groaned. I am now ten episodes in and I'm committed for the duration. This is chronicle of the ups and downs of a single couple relationship and uses the technique of dropping in on specific eras of their relationship in the same fashion as a movie like "Same Time Next Year". This is a very contrived way of telling a story that hits the points that story teller wants to present but it all seems like jumping to critical events and skipping developing fully rounded characters. After watching ten episodes all I can gather about this story is beyond all the ups and downs and ins and outs, these two are bound by a fate that that they can only get along with each other yet they seem to find ways to make one or both miserable. it was an interesting tale at first but after a few cycles of rinse and repeat it just got annoying. They should really just settle for cultivating their love for each other and that's the happy ending. So is this title of "Normal People" suggesting that we all are like ships passing in the night and happiness is always elusive. The thing is I kind of dislike both of these people because the pattern seems what they want to choose and I don't think that this is normal. So all in all I found this a very depressing view of humanity that was frustrating to watch and cannot recommend as entertainment.
Sunday, February 23, 2020
Good Old Wallace
Tim Peters
GOOD OLD NEON” is a short story written by David Foster Wallace and originally published just three months after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, in an issue of the journal Conjunctions. The story was anthologized in the O. Henry Prize Stories 2002 and was included in Oblivion, Wallace’s final collection of short fiction, which was released four years before Wallace committed suicide in the fall of 2008.
“Good Old Neon” is about the life and the death (by suicide, in a car wreck) of a phony, successful, 29-year-old yuppie named Neal, whose ghost narrates the story from beyond the grave in a style that’s uncharacteristically (for Wallace) jargon free and conventionally told.
Much of “Good Old Neon” is about a disappointing round of therapy Neal has with a psychologist named Dr. Gustafson, “a big soft older guy with a big ginger mustache and a pleasant, sort of informal manner.” (A description that brings to mind Robin Williams’s bearded, warmhearted, therapist character from Good Will Hunting, a movie Wallace was fond of, the title of which sounds a lot like “Good Old Neon,” and the story of which is also about a talented young white guy raised by foster parents who is trapped in a cycle of inauthentic behavior.) Despite hoping otherwise, Neal soon finds that Dr. G. “didn’t appear to have anything close to the firepower I’d need to give me any hope of getting helped out of the trap of fraudulence and unhappiness I’d constructed for myself.”
The word “firepower” is used seven times in “Good Old Neon,” and it’s via a fiery explosion that Neal commits suicide and baptizes himself into the land where the hands of the clocks don’t move. “The reality is that dying isn’t bad, but it takes forever. And that forever is no time at all,” he says.
In the story’s final paragraph, just as Neal is crashing his blue Corvette into a highway bridge abutment in the outskirts of the suburbs of Chicago, and just as the car is going up in flames, the perspective jumps to and hovers over “David Wallace,” who’s looking at his 1980 high school yearbook and at a picture of Neal and trying “to somehow reconcile what this luminous guy had seemed like from the outside with whatever on the interior must have driven him to kill himself in such a dramatic and doubtlessly painful way.” The Wallace character is also trying to stifle the growling cynical awareness in him that says wanting to imagine your way empathetically into someone else’s psyche is not only impossible but also worthy of the most asshole-ish of smirks. The final lines of the story go: “the realer, more enduring and sentimental part of [Wallace] commanding that other part to be silent as if looking it levelly in the eye and saying, almost aloud, ‘Not another word.’”
As a short story about a doomed and miserable but intelligent American male, “Good Old Neon” has a number of now-canonized literary predecessors. There’s Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown,” which is about a Puritan who sees evil in the woods and the last lines of which could as well apply to Neal: “They carved no hopeful verse upon his tombstone, for his dying hour was gloom.” Or there’s Hemingway’s Harry from “The Snows of Kilimanjaro,” in extremis while on a vacation in Africa, regretful and pissed off and feeling like his life has been one unendingly boozy distraction: “He had destroyed his talent by not using it, by betrayals of himself and what he believed in, by drinking so much that he blunted the edge of his perceptions, by laziness, by sloth, and by snobbery […]. It was a talent all right but instead of using it, he had traded on it.” And too there’s J. D. Salinger’s Seymour Glass, a World War II combat veteran who, like Wallace’s Neal, chooses suicide at the end of “A Perfect Day for Bananafish.”
“Good Old Neon” also alludes to another piece of short fiction, Tolstoy’s novella The Death of Ivan Ilych. The allusion comes in the form of a pocket watch heirloom that Neal receives from his stepmom, via her grandfather. Inscribed on the watch is a motto in Latin, respice finem, the translation of which — “Consider the end” — makes Neal’s skin crawl. Respice finem is what’s inscribed on a medallion that Ivan Ilych hangs from his pocket watch when he graduates from law school. And as the Honorable Judge Ilych is writhing and sick and only weeks from his death, he, too, feels, like Neal, that his life has been nothing but a farce. Tolstoy writes:
It occurred to him that what he had taken for a perfect impossibility — that he had not lived his life as one should — might in fact be the truth. It occurred to him that those scarcely detected impulses to struggle against what the people of highest social rank considered good, those feeble tendencies that he barely noticed and immediately suppressed, might in fact be what was real, and everything else what was false. His career, all the arrangements of his life and his family, his social and professional ambitions — each of them might be false. He tried to defend it all to himself, and suddenly the weakness of what he was defending became palpable to him. There was nothing, nothing to defend.
But whereas Ivan Ilych only fleetingly thinks himself a phony, Wallace’s Neal is so obsessed with his inauthenticity that he can seem to have more in common, consciousness-wise, with Dostoevsky’s Underground Man — the wretched, spiteful, rambling star of Notes from Underground — than he does with Tolstoy’s Ilych. (And in fact, Wallace dismissed Ilych in his review of a book about Dostoevsky, saying: “You need only compare the protagonists’ final conversions in Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilych and FMD’s Crime and Punishment in order to appreciate Dostoevsky’s ability to be moral without being moralistic.”) You can almost hear a prophecy of Neal’s suicide when the Underground Man rails:
Even if man really were nothing but a piano-key, even if this were proved to him by natural science and mathematics, even then he would not become reasonable, but would purposely do something perverse out of simple ingratitude, simply to gain his point. And if he does not find means he will contrive destruction and chaos, will contrive sufferings of all sorts, only to gain his point! He will launch a curse upon the world, and as only man can curse (it is his privilege, the primary distinction between him and other animals), maybe by his curse alone he will attain his object — that is, convince himself that he is a man and not a piano-key!
And as far as Russian references go, you wonder, too, if Neal’s name is not a coded reference to nihilism. If you pronounce nihilism with a long e sound at the beginning, (the way nihilo in ex nihilo is still often pronounced) then Neal is a homophone of the Latin word nihil (“nothing”). As if Neal is, like the name of that Pearl Jam song, the “Nothingman.” The American nihilist, par excellence.
While Neal has stuff in common with a variety of unhappy, 19th-century Russian protagonists, he suffers and dies in a way that’s unique to a latter-day American techno-consumerist, i.e., he’s a junky, but what he’s addicted to is himself.
Neal says that what’s driving both his phoniness and his success is “the fraudulence paradox,” the viciously cyclical logic of which goes:
The more time and effort you put into trying to appear impressive or attractive to other people, the less impressive or attractive you felt inside — you were a fraud. And the more of a fraud you felt like, the harder you tried to convey an impressive or likable image of yourself so that other people wouldn’t find out what a hollow, fraudulent person you really were.
In a 2011 article for The Awl, Maria Bustillos went through David Foster Wallace’s archive at the Ransom Center at the University of Texas and found a number of self-help and psychology books that he owned, highlighted, and marked up. One of these books was The Drama of the Gifted Child by the psychologist Alice Miller, a passage of which describes in similar language Neal’s problem:
Quite often I have been faced with people who were praised and admired for their talents and their achievements, who were toilet-trained in the first year of their lives, and who may even, at the age of one and a half to five, have capably helped to take care of their younger siblings. According to prevailing attitudes, these people — the pride of their parents — should have had a strong and stable sense of self-assurance. But the case is exactly the opposite. They do well, even excellently, in everything they undertake; they are admired and envied; they are successful whenever they care to be — but behind all this lurks depression, a feeling of emptiness and self-alienation, and a sense that their life has no meaning. These dark feelings will come to the fore as soon as the drug of grandiosity fails, as soon as they are not “on top,” not definitely the “superstar,” or whenever they suddenly get the feeling they have failed to live up to some ideal image or have not measured up to some standard. Then they are plagued by anxiety or deep feelings of guilt and shame.
Miller says a symptom of this “self-alienation” is having dreams in which you see yourself as “at least partly dead.” At one point in “Good Old Neon,” Neal has a dream in which he sees a statue of himself in a suburban town square. He’s cleaning and carving the statue as the people from his life come and go around him and as the sun and the moon spin through the sky. “I’m condemned to a whole life of being nothing but a sort of custodian to the statue,” he says. “I’d somehow chosen to cast my lot with my life’s drama’s supposed audience instead of with the drama itself.”
Miller says,
Narcissus was in love with his idealized picture, but neither the grandiose nor the depressive “Narcissus” can really love himself. His passion for his false self makes impossible not only love for others but also, despite all appearances, love for the one person who is fully entrusted to his care: himself.
Likewise, Neal wonders toward the end of the story if his problem isn’t so much one of being phony and self-centered all the time as really just being incapable of love. He says,
Being unable to really love was at least a different model or lens through which to see the problem, plus initially it seemed like a promising way of attacking the fraudulence paradox in terms of reducing the self-hatred part that reinforced the fear and the consequent drive to try to manipulate people intro providing the very approval I’d denied myself.
But then Neal is awake one night watching TV and comes across a rerun of Cheers. The psychologist characters Frasier and Lilith walk down into the bar and Frasier asks Lilith how her day was. She says, “If I have one more yuppie come in and start whining to me about how he can’t love, I’m going to throw up.” The audience bursts into laughter. Neal decides it’s time to die.
Just as Neal’s about to get in his car and go crash it into the bridge abutment, he says,
All right, now we’re coming to what I promised and led you through the whole dull synopsis of what led up to this in hopes of. Meaning what it’s like to die, what happens. Right? This is what everyone wants to know. And you do, trust me. Whether you decide to go through with it or not, whether I somehow talk you out of it the way you think I’m going to try and do or not.
Who is Neal talking to here? Talking who out of doing what?
Early on in the story, Neal says,
What I mean is that it doesn’t really matter what you think about me, because despite appearances this isn’t even really about me. All I’m trying to do is sketch out one little part of what it was like before I died and why I at least thought I did it, so that you’ll have at least some idea of why what happened afterward happened and why it had the impact it did on who this is really about.
Who is Neal referring to here about the story having an impact on? To the “David Wallace” character who’s looking at his high school yearbook and at a picture of Neal in the final page and a half of the story?
If you read “Good Old Neon” and then read D. T. Max’s biography of Wallace, Every Love Story Is a Ghost Story (the epigraph of which is a line from “Neon”), you see one example after another of stuff from Wallace’s life that Neal says happened to him. Being raised by people “of high ideals and values, humanists”; making fun of his sister as a kid and pretending like she was obese and jumping out of the way when she passed him in the hallway; having a knack for mathematical logic and logical paradoxes; having “a killer G.P.A.”; playing a varsity sport; being a philanderer with women; being on the professional fast track by the time he was in his 20s; getting into religion and meditation as a way of dealing with his troubles; living in the vicinity of the cornfields of Illinois; committing suicide. At the end of the story, when Neal’s ghost is hovering over Wallace and their high school yearbook, and as the latter is thinking about how impossible it is to try and pass through the exterior image of a person and to enter into the realm of his psyche, you wonder if what’s really going on in this story is something more akin to what happens between Dorian Gray and his picture, or William Wilson and his double, or Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, or Bruce Banner and the Incredible Hulk, or the two Tyler Durdens in Fight Club, or even between Martin Sheen and his reflection in the mirror in Hearts of Darkness, which is to say, you wonder if what’s going on here is a sort of a spiritual/philosophical death match, a duel between two opposite tendencies that are internal to a psyche but in the world of these stories are teased into two separate but similar-looking characters, into doubles or doppelgängers who both need each other and then perversely also try to destroy each other. And the dialectic that these characters are working out is Apollo v. Dionysus, the superego v. the id, the false self v. the true self, the rational civilized scientific order v. spontaneity and passion and a community of spirit. The drama that makes these stories interesting is that there’s no boring, middling, mediating ego term to calm things down and to make concessions and to prevent the dialectic from exploding. Hence: Dorian Gray stabs himself; William Wilson stabs himself; Mr. Hyde is either going to be executed or to commit suicide; The Hulk goes Smash; Tyler Durden shoots himself; Martin Sheen has a heart attack and has to be flown off the set of Apocalypse Now. And as for “Good Old Neon,” the struggle is between Neal, the golden child, against the “real, more enduring and sentimental” David Wallace who’s looking at their pictures in the high school yearbook. It’s the struggle between a nihilist who’s yet actively making the society function, and a believer who has a desire for solid, non-alienated, human relationships, but who’s quietly, sadly, sitting in a recliner and watching the nihilists run.
When the Grand Inquisitor and Jesus face off in The Brothers Karamazov (and if there were ever a literary dialectical death match, this is it: Christ v. Anti-Christ), the Inquisitor talks and talks and talks, explaining with precision and with logic why the elaborate lies and laws and ideology of the Church are necessary to keep people happy and at peace. Jesus listens, says nothing, then embraces the Inquisitor.
Is that what’s going on in “Good Old Neon”? That Neal is talking, and David Wallace is listening? And that what’s darkly, deceptively tragic about all this is that “Good Old Neon” itself is still more or less a symptom of a self-centered need to perform, to show off, to be impressive to others (even if it’s with the most excruciating, impeccable, brutal honesty)? That to explain and to show very clearly in elegant prose what a phony, self-centered piece of shit you are doesn’t make you any less of a phony, self-centered piece of shit?
It’s interesting to look at the differences in the endings of “Good Old Neon” and Good Will Hunting. Both stories have their talented young men alone in their cars, driving off westwardly into a new state of being. The closing credits of Good Will Hunting show Will on his way to California in order to try and have an actual, full-on, loving relationship with Minnie Driver’s character, Skylar, while Elliott Smith’s “Miss Misery” plays on the soundtrack. In “Good Old Neon,” Neal is driving into the cornfields in the exurbs of Chicago in order to kill himself privately and to, as it were, run through life’s fire escape. Will decides to grow up. Neal decides to give up. It’s all very similar to what happens in Walker Percy’s The Moviegoer, in which Binx Bolling is, like Neal, 29 years old and is going through an apocalyptic life crisis and feeling like he’s living in “the great shithouse of scientific humanism.” Binx says, “On this my thirtieth birthday, I know nothing and there is nothing to do but fall prey to desire.” But Percy doesn’t make his Binx commit suicide or go permanently on the run. He has him get married and commit his energy to someone who’s other than himself.
Is “Good Old Neon” then a sort of vivid, pessimistic prophecy? A vision of a psyche that for some troublingly deep, fundamental, almost a priori reason is both unable and unwilling to grow up and to evolve and to participate in the world as a responsible adult? Could it be that this anxiety is also what’s hiding behind prose fiction’s societal malaise, and behind the troubles Wallace was having while he worked on The Pale King? That plain old unadorned narrative prose has just become more or less culturally impotent and exhausted and unable to extricate itself from the spiral of inauthenticity? Could it be there’s a not-arbitrary reason the David Wallace character at the end of “Good Old Neon” is looking at a picture of his doppelgänger Neal, one that’s embedded in the concatenation of little pictures that constitute the page of a high school yearbook, a text that in combining images and words is basically a proto-graphic novel? As if, for whatever obscurely Hegelian dialectical reasons, the psyche of the society has taken a very clever atavistic twist and is unfolding from itself a kind of reversion to the era of the ideogram, the hieroglyph, the pictograph? And that a reader today just can’t trust or take seriously or have a mature, adult, non-solipsistic relationship with an author who doesn’t know how to build something necessarily visual into the stuff that they make? And could it be that if you’re a writer who is unwilling or unable to mix design and to mix images into the fiber of the material you’re working on, then, reader-writer rhetoric-wise, you will be Talking to a Wall? That you’ll be like WALL-E, sorting through the detritus, left behind on the withered husk of an earth, while your youthful, tech-savvy, image-fluent usurpers will be up in their orbiters, preparing for the mission to Jupiter?
There’s more than a few young readers out there who, when really getting into the thick of the plot of Infinite Jest, thought secretly to themselves, “Jesus, it’s over. Prose fiction is over. And this book is its elegy.” Wallace’s footnotes were a way to build a fractal structure visually into a work of prose, and thereby to communicate through a method that was mimetic of his readers’ daily state of mind. But Wallace was part of the last generation of writers to grow up without video games or PCs or the Internet, and for those of us whose minds were structured in imitation of all that unhealthily febrile textual kinesis, we are craving desperately a literary movement that can express itself in just those terms. Cartoonists like Chris Ware, Dan Clowes, Seth, Adrian Tomine, Ivan Brunetti, Charles Burns, and Alison Bechdel have been doing this since the ’90s via the tradition of comics and the graphic novel (and Art Spiegelman and Alan Moore and Frank Miller did it before them as predecessors in the 1980s), but the circumstances have never been better/more dire/more fecund for the children of the ’80s and the children of the ’90s to shoulder some responsibility and to just fucking grow up already and, in the still-smoldering wreckage of Wallace’s demise, to fuse together a new kind of writing, a new kind of reading, and a new kind of escape from the good old consumerist death trap.
Tim Peters
GOOD OLD NEON” is a short story written by David Foster Wallace and originally published just three months after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, in an issue of the journal Conjunctions. The story was anthologized in the O. Henry Prize Stories 2002 and was included in Oblivion, Wallace’s final collection of short fiction, which was released four years before Wallace committed suicide in the fall of 2008.
“Good Old Neon” is about the life and the death (by suicide, in a car wreck) of a phony, successful, 29-year-old yuppie named Neal, whose ghost narrates the story from beyond the grave in a style that’s uncharacteristically (for Wallace) jargon free and conventionally told.
Much of “Good Old Neon” is about a disappointing round of therapy Neal has with a psychologist named Dr. Gustafson, “a big soft older guy with a big ginger mustache and a pleasant, sort of informal manner.” (A description that brings to mind Robin Williams’s bearded, warmhearted, therapist character from Good Will Hunting, a movie Wallace was fond of, the title of which sounds a lot like “Good Old Neon,” and the story of which is also about a talented young white guy raised by foster parents who is trapped in a cycle of inauthentic behavior.) Despite hoping otherwise, Neal soon finds that Dr. G. “didn’t appear to have anything close to the firepower I’d need to give me any hope of getting helped out of the trap of fraudulence and unhappiness I’d constructed for myself.”
The word “firepower” is used seven times in “Good Old Neon,” and it’s via a fiery explosion that Neal commits suicide and baptizes himself into the land where the hands of the clocks don’t move. “The reality is that dying isn’t bad, but it takes forever. And that forever is no time at all,” he says.
In the story’s final paragraph, just as Neal is crashing his blue Corvette into a highway bridge abutment in the outskirts of the suburbs of Chicago, and just as the car is going up in flames, the perspective jumps to and hovers over “David Wallace,” who’s looking at his 1980 high school yearbook and at a picture of Neal and trying “to somehow reconcile what this luminous guy had seemed like from the outside with whatever on the interior must have driven him to kill himself in such a dramatic and doubtlessly painful way.” The Wallace character is also trying to stifle the growling cynical awareness in him that says wanting to imagine your way empathetically into someone else’s psyche is not only impossible but also worthy of the most asshole-ish of smirks. The final lines of the story go: “the realer, more enduring and sentimental part of [Wallace] commanding that other part to be silent as if looking it levelly in the eye and saying, almost aloud, ‘Not another word.’”
As a short story about a doomed and miserable but intelligent American male, “Good Old Neon” has a number of now-canonized literary predecessors. There’s Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown,” which is about a Puritan who sees evil in the woods and the last lines of which could as well apply to Neal: “They carved no hopeful verse upon his tombstone, for his dying hour was gloom.” Or there’s Hemingway’s Harry from “The Snows of Kilimanjaro,” in extremis while on a vacation in Africa, regretful and pissed off and feeling like his life has been one unendingly boozy distraction: “He had destroyed his talent by not using it, by betrayals of himself and what he believed in, by drinking so much that he blunted the edge of his perceptions, by laziness, by sloth, and by snobbery […]. It was a talent all right but instead of using it, he had traded on it.” And too there’s J. D. Salinger’s Seymour Glass, a World War II combat veteran who, like Wallace’s Neal, chooses suicide at the end of “A Perfect Day for Bananafish.”
“Good Old Neon” also alludes to another piece of short fiction, Tolstoy’s novella The Death of Ivan Ilych. The allusion comes in the form of a pocket watch heirloom that Neal receives from his stepmom, via her grandfather. Inscribed on the watch is a motto in Latin, respice finem, the translation of which — “Consider the end” — makes Neal’s skin crawl. Respice finem is what’s inscribed on a medallion that Ivan Ilych hangs from his pocket watch when he graduates from law school. And as the Honorable Judge Ilych is writhing and sick and only weeks from his death, he, too, feels, like Neal, that his life has been nothing but a farce. Tolstoy writes:
It occurred to him that what he had taken for a perfect impossibility — that he had not lived his life as one should — might in fact be the truth. It occurred to him that those scarcely detected impulses to struggle against what the people of highest social rank considered good, those feeble tendencies that he barely noticed and immediately suppressed, might in fact be what was real, and everything else what was false. His career, all the arrangements of his life and his family, his social and professional ambitions — each of them might be false. He tried to defend it all to himself, and suddenly the weakness of what he was defending became palpable to him. There was nothing, nothing to defend.
But whereas Ivan Ilych only fleetingly thinks himself a phony, Wallace’s Neal is so obsessed with his inauthenticity that he can seem to have more in common, consciousness-wise, with Dostoevsky’s Underground Man — the wretched, spiteful, rambling star of Notes from Underground — than he does with Tolstoy’s Ilych. (And in fact, Wallace dismissed Ilych in his review of a book about Dostoevsky, saying: “You need only compare the protagonists’ final conversions in Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilych and FMD’s Crime and Punishment in order to appreciate Dostoevsky’s ability to be moral without being moralistic.”) You can almost hear a prophecy of Neal’s suicide when the Underground Man rails:
Even if man really were nothing but a piano-key, even if this were proved to him by natural science and mathematics, even then he would not become reasonable, but would purposely do something perverse out of simple ingratitude, simply to gain his point. And if he does not find means he will contrive destruction and chaos, will contrive sufferings of all sorts, only to gain his point! He will launch a curse upon the world, and as only man can curse (it is his privilege, the primary distinction between him and other animals), maybe by his curse alone he will attain his object — that is, convince himself that he is a man and not a piano-key!
And as far as Russian references go, you wonder, too, if Neal’s name is not a coded reference to nihilism. If you pronounce nihilism with a long e sound at the beginning, (the way nihilo in ex nihilo is still often pronounced) then Neal is a homophone of the Latin word nihil (“nothing”). As if Neal is, like the name of that Pearl Jam song, the “Nothingman.” The American nihilist, par excellence.
While Neal has stuff in common with a variety of unhappy, 19th-century Russian protagonists, he suffers and dies in a way that’s unique to a latter-day American techno-consumerist, i.e., he’s a junky, but what he’s addicted to is himself.
Neal says that what’s driving both his phoniness and his success is “the fraudulence paradox,” the viciously cyclical logic of which goes:
The more time and effort you put into trying to appear impressive or attractive to other people, the less impressive or attractive you felt inside — you were a fraud. And the more of a fraud you felt like, the harder you tried to convey an impressive or likable image of yourself so that other people wouldn’t find out what a hollow, fraudulent person you really were.
In a 2011 article for The Awl, Maria Bustillos went through David Foster Wallace’s archive at the Ransom Center at the University of Texas and found a number of self-help and psychology books that he owned, highlighted, and marked up. One of these books was The Drama of the Gifted Child by the psychologist Alice Miller, a passage of which describes in similar language Neal’s problem:
Quite often I have been faced with people who were praised and admired for their talents and their achievements, who were toilet-trained in the first year of their lives, and who may even, at the age of one and a half to five, have capably helped to take care of their younger siblings. According to prevailing attitudes, these people — the pride of their parents — should have had a strong and stable sense of self-assurance. But the case is exactly the opposite. They do well, even excellently, in everything they undertake; they are admired and envied; they are successful whenever they care to be — but behind all this lurks depression, a feeling of emptiness and self-alienation, and a sense that their life has no meaning. These dark feelings will come to the fore as soon as the drug of grandiosity fails, as soon as they are not “on top,” not definitely the “superstar,” or whenever they suddenly get the feeling they have failed to live up to some ideal image or have not measured up to some standard. Then they are plagued by anxiety or deep feelings of guilt and shame.
Miller says a symptom of this “self-alienation” is having dreams in which you see yourself as “at least partly dead.” At one point in “Good Old Neon,” Neal has a dream in which he sees a statue of himself in a suburban town square. He’s cleaning and carving the statue as the people from his life come and go around him and as the sun and the moon spin through the sky. “I’m condemned to a whole life of being nothing but a sort of custodian to the statue,” he says. “I’d somehow chosen to cast my lot with my life’s drama’s supposed audience instead of with the drama itself.”
Miller says,
Narcissus was in love with his idealized picture, but neither the grandiose nor the depressive “Narcissus” can really love himself. His passion for his false self makes impossible not only love for others but also, despite all appearances, love for the one person who is fully entrusted to his care: himself.
Likewise, Neal wonders toward the end of the story if his problem isn’t so much one of being phony and self-centered all the time as really just being incapable of love. He says,
Being unable to really love was at least a different model or lens through which to see the problem, plus initially it seemed like a promising way of attacking the fraudulence paradox in terms of reducing the self-hatred part that reinforced the fear and the consequent drive to try to manipulate people intro providing the very approval I’d denied myself.
But then Neal is awake one night watching TV and comes across a rerun of Cheers. The psychologist characters Frasier and Lilith walk down into the bar and Frasier asks Lilith how her day was. She says, “If I have one more yuppie come in and start whining to me about how he can’t love, I’m going to throw up.” The audience bursts into laughter. Neal decides it’s time to die.
Just as Neal’s about to get in his car and go crash it into the bridge abutment, he says,
All right, now we’re coming to what I promised and led you through the whole dull synopsis of what led up to this in hopes of. Meaning what it’s like to die, what happens. Right? This is what everyone wants to know. And you do, trust me. Whether you decide to go through with it or not, whether I somehow talk you out of it the way you think I’m going to try and do or not.
Who is Neal talking to here? Talking who out of doing what?
Early on in the story, Neal says,
What I mean is that it doesn’t really matter what you think about me, because despite appearances this isn’t even really about me. All I’m trying to do is sketch out one little part of what it was like before I died and why I at least thought I did it, so that you’ll have at least some idea of why what happened afterward happened and why it had the impact it did on who this is really about.
Who is Neal referring to here about the story having an impact on? To the “David Wallace” character who’s looking at his high school yearbook and at a picture of Neal in the final page and a half of the story?
If you read “Good Old Neon” and then read D. T. Max’s biography of Wallace, Every Love Story Is a Ghost Story (the epigraph of which is a line from “Neon”), you see one example after another of stuff from Wallace’s life that Neal says happened to him. Being raised by people “of high ideals and values, humanists”; making fun of his sister as a kid and pretending like she was obese and jumping out of the way when she passed him in the hallway; having a knack for mathematical logic and logical paradoxes; having “a killer G.P.A.”; playing a varsity sport; being a philanderer with women; being on the professional fast track by the time he was in his 20s; getting into religion and meditation as a way of dealing with his troubles; living in the vicinity of the cornfields of Illinois; committing suicide. At the end of the story, when Neal’s ghost is hovering over Wallace and their high school yearbook, and as the latter is thinking about how impossible it is to try and pass through the exterior image of a person and to enter into the realm of his psyche, you wonder if what’s really going on in this story is something more akin to what happens between Dorian Gray and his picture, or William Wilson and his double, or Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, or Bruce Banner and the Incredible Hulk, or the two Tyler Durdens in Fight Club, or even between Martin Sheen and his reflection in the mirror in Hearts of Darkness, which is to say, you wonder if what’s going on here is a sort of a spiritual/philosophical death match, a duel between two opposite tendencies that are internal to a psyche but in the world of these stories are teased into two separate but similar-looking characters, into doubles or doppelgängers who both need each other and then perversely also try to destroy each other. And the dialectic that these characters are working out is Apollo v. Dionysus, the superego v. the id, the false self v. the true self, the rational civilized scientific order v. spontaneity and passion and a community of spirit. The drama that makes these stories interesting is that there’s no boring, middling, mediating ego term to calm things down and to make concessions and to prevent the dialectic from exploding. Hence: Dorian Gray stabs himself; William Wilson stabs himself; Mr. Hyde is either going to be executed or to commit suicide; The Hulk goes Smash; Tyler Durden shoots himself; Martin Sheen has a heart attack and has to be flown off the set of Apocalypse Now. And as for “Good Old Neon,” the struggle is between Neal, the golden child, against the “real, more enduring and sentimental” David Wallace who’s looking at their pictures in the high school yearbook. It’s the struggle between a nihilist who’s yet actively making the society function, and a believer who has a desire for solid, non-alienated, human relationships, but who’s quietly, sadly, sitting in a recliner and watching the nihilists run.
When the Grand Inquisitor and Jesus face off in The Brothers Karamazov (and if there were ever a literary dialectical death match, this is it: Christ v. Anti-Christ), the Inquisitor talks and talks and talks, explaining with precision and with logic why the elaborate lies and laws and ideology of the Church are necessary to keep people happy and at peace. Jesus listens, says nothing, then embraces the Inquisitor.
Is that what’s going on in “Good Old Neon”? That Neal is talking, and David Wallace is listening? And that what’s darkly, deceptively tragic about all this is that “Good Old Neon” itself is still more or less a symptom of a self-centered need to perform, to show off, to be impressive to others (even if it’s with the most excruciating, impeccable, brutal honesty)? That to explain and to show very clearly in elegant prose what a phony, self-centered piece of shit you are doesn’t make you any less of a phony, self-centered piece of shit?
It’s interesting to look at the differences in the endings of “Good Old Neon” and Good Will Hunting. Both stories have their talented young men alone in their cars, driving off westwardly into a new state of being. The closing credits of Good Will Hunting show Will on his way to California in order to try and have an actual, full-on, loving relationship with Minnie Driver’s character, Skylar, while Elliott Smith’s “Miss Misery” plays on the soundtrack. In “Good Old Neon,” Neal is driving into the cornfields in the exurbs of Chicago in order to kill himself privately and to, as it were, run through life’s fire escape. Will decides to grow up. Neal decides to give up. It’s all very similar to what happens in Walker Percy’s The Moviegoer, in which Binx Bolling is, like Neal, 29 years old and is going through an apocalyptic life crisis and feeling like he’s living in “the great shithouse of scientific humanism.” Binx says, “On this my thirtieth birthday, I know nothing and there is nothing to do but fall prey to desire.” But Percy doesn’t make his Binx commit suicide or go permanently on the run. He has him get married and commit his energy to someone who’s other than himself.
Is “Good Old Neon” then a sort of vivid, pessimistic prophecy? A vision of a psyche that for some troublingly deep, fundamental, almost a priori reason is both unable and unwilling to grow up and to evolve and to participate in the world as a responsible adult? Could it be that this anxiety is also what’s hiding behind prose fiction’s societal malaise, and behind the troubles Wallace was having while he worked on The Pale King? That plain old unadorned narrative prose has just become more or less culturally impotent and exhausted and unable to extricate itself from the spiral of inauthenticity? Could it be there’s a not-arbitrary reason the David Wallace character at the end of “Good Old Neon” is looking at a picture of his doppelgänger Neal, one that’s embedded in the concatenation of little pictures that constitute the page of a high school yearbook, a text that in combining images and words is basically a proto-graphic novel? As if, for whatever obscurely Hegelian dialectical reasons, the psyche of the society has taken a very clever atavistic twist and is unfolding from itself a kind of reversion to the era of the ideogram, the hieroglyph, the pictograph? And that a reader today just can’t trust or take seriously or have a mature, adult, non-solipsistic relationship with an author who doesn’t know how to build something necessarily visual into the stuff that they make? And could it be that if you’re a writer who is unwilling or unable to mix design and to mix images into the fiber of the material you’re working on, then, reader-writer rhetoric-wise, you will be Talking to a Wall? That you’ll be like WALL-E, sorting through the detritus, left behind on the withered husk of an earth, while your youthful, tech-savvy, image-fluent usurpers will be up in their orbiters, preparing for the mission to Jupiter?
There’s more than a few young readers out there who, when really getting into the thick of the plot of Infinite Jest, thought secretly to themselves, “Jesus, it’s over. Prose fiction is over. And this book is its elegy.” Wallace’s footnotes were a way to build a fractal structure visually into a work of prose, and thereby to communicate through a method that was mimetic of his readers’ daily state of mind. But Wallace was part of the last generation of writers to grow up without video games or PCs or the Internet, and for those of us whose minds were structured in imitation of all that unhealthily febrile textual kinesis, we are craving desperately a literary movement that can express itself in just those terms. Cartoonists like Chris Ware, Dan Clowes, Seth, Adrian Tomine, Ivan Brunetti, Charles Burns, and Alison Bechdel have been doing this since the ’90s via the tradition of comics and the graphic novel (and Art Spiegelman and Alan Moore and Frank Miller did it before them as predecessors in the 1980s), but the circumstances have never been better/more dire/more fecund for the children of the ’80s and the children of the ’90s to shoulder some responsibility and to just fucking grow up already and, in the still-smoldering wreckage of Wallace’s demise, to fuse together a new kind of writing, a new kind of reading, and a new kind of escape from the good old consumerist death trap.
Tuesday, January 7, 2020
Christmas 2019
My kids had left by 2pm, off to their next family commitments. I was in some strange state that is a cross between tiredness from wrapping presents at 2 am which is a personal tradition and that empty vague let down of an anticipated event organized and fulfilled and now you can go back to my default retirement condition of nothing I have to do. It is always an odd feeling where something is so enough unpleasant about the present moment that you are lost in a state of remembering just what happened in that time where you were in a world of other people and family. I am hesitant to clean up and move things because every object in it's location recalls specific people doing specific things; the quiche sitting on the stove was being put in the oven by my son girlfriend and now mother of Rose this morning when I first walked into the kitchen this Christmas morning. Rose's mickey mouse bottle was on the lizard table that she was walking around with. It was her first Christmas at age one and a half where she had any sense of a special day where there were things with colored wraps to be pulled off.
I don't know that there is any word to describes this feeling of noting an end to some event: this post partem letdown. I can't be the only one who experiences it and old age certainly plays its part. It is the mirror image of a more recognized phenomenological experience, that of waiting. The word that comes to mind is wistfulness which is not a common word and implies a certain regret which I don't think exactly pertains. But lets call it that. It is the other end of the tunnel, the darkness being the unknown sequence of happening that is the excitement of being around others and not knowing what will unfold. On the phenomena of waiting, Heidegger in his opus Being and Time discusses how waiting brings an awareness of time that we face and cannot get lost from. And Time brings the dread of unbecoming facing times end in our death. Sartre makes one of his most essential distinctions when he talk about being in itself and being-for-itself. Being-in-itself, is our desire to be a kind of a god. This is a longing for total control over one's destiny and for absolute identity. No questioning or doubt. This is the world of perceived objects. This is certainly a very sophisticated and ironic view of the divine. But we, alas, are being-for-itself and or always confronted by a state of questioning. I've drifted a bit far afield but what I have termed wistfulness is wrapped in this.
My kids had left by 2pm, off to their next family commitments. I was in some strange state that is a cross between tiredness from wrapping presents at 2 am which is a personal tradition and that empty vague let down of an anticipated event organized and fulfilled and now you can go back to my default retirement condition of nothing I have to do. It is always an odd feeling where something is so enough unpleasant about the present moment that you are lost in a state of remembering just what happened in that time where you were in a world of other people and family. I am hesitant to clean up and move things because every object in it's location recalls specific people doing specific things; the quiche sitting on the stove was being put in the oven by my son girlfriend and now mother of Rose this morning when I first walked into the kitchen this Christmas morning. Rose's mickey mouse bottle was on the lizard table that she was walking around with. It was her first Christmas at age one and a half where she had any sense of a special day where there were things with colored wraps to be pulled off.
I don't know that there is any word to describes this feeling of noting an end to some event: this post partem letdown. I can't be the only one who experiences it and old age certainly plays its part. It is the mirror image of a more recognized phenomenological experience, that of waiting. The word that comes to mind is wistfulness which is not a common word and implies a certain regret which I don't think exactly pertains. But lets call it that. It is the other end of the tunnel, the darkness being the unknown sequence of happening that is the excitement of being around others and not knowing what will unfold. On the phenomena of waiting, Heidegger in his opus Being and Time discusses how waiting brings an awareness of time that we face and cannot get lost from. And Time brings the dread of unbecoming facing times end in our death. Sartre makes one of his most essential distinctions when he talk about being in itself and being-for-itself. Being-in-itself, is our desire to be a kind of a god. This is a longing for total control over one's destiny and for absolute identity. No questioning or doubt. This is the world of perceived objects. This is certainly a very sophisticated and ironic view of the divine. But we, alas, are being-for-itself and or always confronted by a state of questioning. I've drifted a bit far afield but what I have termed wistfulness is wrapped in this.
Friday, November 15, 2019
In the realm of why people have lost faith in professional elites. I read this from the Bloomington Herald Times dated Oct 29 with the headline "IU bus service changes weighed" and to quote
"Last year Bloomington Monroe County Metropolitan Planning Organization approved spending $250,000 of federal dollars that it recieves to conduct route optimization study for Bloomington Transit and IU Bus. Bloomington Transit paid the 20% local match required to use the funds".
And what was the outcome? They decide to make 2 changes, but here goes
"Evan though the consultants with Foursquare FTP recommended several other changes IU Campus Bus director, Brian Noojin said they do not plan one implementing them at this time"
And what is the reason for this?
"the main reason we are not implementing these is that it would require 15 buses to be routed through the heart of campus on E. 7th Street and around Showalter Fountain. This is not feasible for the physical space required"
So if I am getting this right, they spent $300,000 on a study that if the consultants had any situational awareness of the actual facts on the ground here, they should have never recommended. This kind of questionable spending on consultants is endemic to many levels and divisions of the city government. I know from my experience working at the county library where they spent $80,000 on a survey on concerns about the library and discovered that by far the biggest issue was lack of parking, something that everyone was well aware of. Not only is this an irresponsible use of public money but when people become distrustful and cynical about experts then they start doubting legitimate facts like climate change.
"Last year Bloomington Monroe County Metropolitan Planning Organization approved spending $250,000 of federal dollars that it recieves to conduct route optimization study for Bloomington Transit and IU Bus. Bloomington Transit paid the 20% local match required to use the funds".
And what was the outcome? They decide to make 2 changes, but here goes
"Evan though the consultants with Foursquare FTP recommended several other changes IU Campus Bus director, Brian Noojin said they do not plan one implementing them at this time"
And what is the reason for this?
"the main reason we are not implementing these is that it would require 15 buses to be routed through the heart of campus on E. 7th Street and around Showalter Fountain. This is not feasible for the physical space required"
So if I am getting this right, they spent $300,000 on a study that if the consultants had any situational awareness of the actual facts on the ground here, they should have never recommended. This kind of questionable spending on consultants is endemic to many levels and divisions of the city government. I know from my experience working at the county library where they spent $80,000 on a survey on concerns about the library and discovered that by far the biggest issue was lack of parking, something that everyone was well aware of. Not only is this an irresponsible use of public money but when people become distrustful and cynical about experts then they start doubting legitimate facts like climate change.
Tuesday, November 5, 2019
My Don Quixote Coarse
I've just completed my 5 week IU continuing education coarse on Don Quixote. This was a shot in the dark for me. I had never read the book and my motive for taking the coarse was that I yearn for a type of conversation that I have not had in decades since my college days. Great literature whether fiction or philosophy provides a common context for a conversation that can be very meaningful and satisfying. This turned into a different experience than I had expected. There were 7 students and the teacher was a 30ish American born Korean girl who was I have to say very pretty but demure and serious. Of the seven students, three just quit showing up about half way through the 5 weeks and they all quit at the same time. Why? I don't know. I am not sure just what they expected out of the coarse. I guess I feel a commitment to stick something like this out. It's five session of one hour and a half. It turned out the the older members stuck it out and maybe that says something. I do wonder why you would even sign up and pay $80 for a coarse of this limited scope. Just what were they expecting? I had not read Don Quixote and I was only able to read 200+ pages in a 900 page book. At my reading speed when I am really trying to absorb every word, to get through this book would have meant a major commitment of hours of reading just about every day. I am just starved for a certain type of conversation that involves something deeper than the little conversations I now have I've missed this since my now lost friend Add Howe died a year ago. I guess what I really hoping for in signing up for these classes is that I will meet the perfect lady and we will click. This getting entirely too revelatory
My thought on Don Quizote
I was very impressed with Cervantes as a very good and especially humorous writer which did make me want to slow down and savor each sentence. It was hard to get into the flow of the book because it is about this fellow who has read to many books of Chivalry, a code of conduct that had run it coarse by the time that Cerantes was around, 1605 to be exact. He is living in a world of delusion that continues for the entire book. The book was written in two parts separated by 10 years and each part treats this delusional living in different ways. The second part was written after part 1 had become popular and it reframes his delusional life with a more positive participation on the part of other characters. The other important character besides Don is Sancho Panza who repeatedly drifts in and out of Dons delusional world like some sort of guy that jumps from on reality to another. This allows Cervantes to write either as a farcical satirist or a rational commentator through Sancho Panza. This was invention of the sidekick device in story telling that has existed for the last 4 centuries. It is hard to draw any kind of long lasting theme from this book because I was not sure how to think of this Chivalry as a serious code because the way Cervantes would have it, you just need a steed, armor, a squire, and a lady of courtly love which is that object that makes all of your actions pure and noble as long as done in her name. This is just hard for the modern mind to relate to. And Catholic religion dominated Spain at this time which complicates how to think of Chivalry. Maybe it was a kind of living mythology such that it would find great popularity which it did. Hard to think of something comparable. I never got a clear view of this in the coarse.
I've just completed my 5 week IU continuing education coarse on Don Quixote. This was a shot in the dark for me. I had never read the book and my motive for taking the coarse was that I yearn for a type of conversation that I have not had in decades since my college days. Great literature whether fiction or philosophy provides a common context for a conversation that can be very meaningful and satisfying. This turned into a different experience than I had expected. There were 7 students and the teacher was a 30ish American born Korean girl who was I have to say very pretty but demure and serious. Of the seven students, three just quit showing up about half way through the 5 weeks and they all quit at the same time. Why? I don't know. I am not sure just what they expected out of the coarse. I guess I feel a commitment to stick something like this out. It's five session of one hour and a half. It turned out the the older members stuck it out and maybe that says something. I do wonder why you would even sign up and pay $80 for a coarse of this limited scope. Just what were they expecting? I had not read Don Quixote and I was only able to read 200+ pages in a 900 page book. At my reading speed when I am really trying to absorb every word, to get through this book would have meant a major commitment of hours of reading just about every day. I am just starved for a certain type of conversation that involves something deeper than the little conversations I now have I've missed this since my now lost friend Add Howe died a year ago. I guess what I really hoping for in signing up for these classes is that I will meet the perfect lady and we will click. This getting entirely too revelatory
My thought on Don Quizote
I was very impressed with Cervantes as a very good and especially humorous writer which did make me want to slow down and savor each sentence. It was hard to get into the flow of the book because it is about this fellow who has read to many books of Chivalry, a code of conduct that had run it coarse by the time that Cerantes was around, 1605 to be exact. He is living in a world of delusion that continues for the entire book. The book was written in two parts separated by 10 years and each part treats this delusional living in different ways. The second part was written after part 1 had become popular and it reframes his delusional life with a more positive participation on the part of other characters. The other important character besides Don is Sancho Panza who repeatedly drifts in and out of Dons delusional world like some sort of guy that jumps from on reality to another. This allows Cervantes to write either as a farcical satirist or a rational commentator through Sancho Panza. This was invention of the sidekick device in story telling that has existed for the last 4 centuries. It is hard to draw any kind of long lasting theme from this book because I was not sure how to think of this Chivalry as a serious code because the way Cervantes would have it, you just need a steed, armor, a squire, and a lady of courtly love which is that object that makes all of your actions pure and noble as long as done in her name. This is just hard for the modern mind to relate to. And Catholic religion dominated Spain at this time which complicates how to think of Chivalry. Maybe it was a kind of living mythology such that it would find great popularity which it did. Hard to think of something comparable. I never got a clear view of this in the coarse.
Sunday, November 26, 2017
The Clouds Of Sils Maria - Round and Round We Go
My dive on this Black Friday of 2017 was into the French/German/Swiss co production movie “The Clouds Of Sils Maria directed by Olivier Assayas and starring the veteran French actress Juliette Binoche, and two up and coming American actresses, Kristen Stewart of “Twilight” fame and Chloe Grace Moretz.
This is a story that is told in mirrored levels. At base, there is a story about the relationship between two women, an established CEO of some mythical corporations and her younger protege. It is a study of the weariness of age and experience versus the energetic yet blind grasp of youth. The actual movie is about Binoche who as a famous established actress on the downward slope of a long career agrees to play the older CEO in the just described story and her young personal assistant played by Kristen Stewart. The essential theme of this movie is simply that the relationship between these two characters in the movie that we are actually viewing is mirrored precisely in the fictional movie that is the subject of the plot. And so we see many scenes where the actress and her assistant are rehearsing scenes but there is this question of at what level we should be interpreting these conversations. Are we hearing a conversation between the actress and the assistant in the movie or the script of the fictional movie? If this sounds confusing, it is meant to be and it kind of works to make what they actually say more interesting.
I don’t usually like movies about people making movies. The idea that what “artists” find worth talking about is obsessing about their own creative efforts is navel gazing indulgence of the most worthless kind. “Clouds Of Sils Maria” works because of this gimmick of confusing the levels of abstraction. There is even a kind of 4th wall further abstraction in the choice of the real actresses to play these parts as they really do have this kind of old pro and new hungry kid vibe in their actual careers. The process is intriguing. What the movie actually tells us is something that I could not fathom.
The scene for much of the movie was very cool as it is set in the Swiss Alps in an area which has what is called the Maloja Pass. This is a beautiful area and their is a cloud phenomena that exist there where low clouds drift down the valley between mountains evoking a magical surrealistic scene. This made me think of that most literate of naval gazers Friedrich Nietzsche and his time in the Swiss Alps and his “Thus Spoke Zarathustra”.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
